diff --git a/app/api/controller/Recovery.php b/app/api/controller/Recovery.php
index 2a64ea5e..62cba2a9 100644
--- a/app/api/controller/Recovery.php
+++ b/app/api/controller/Recovery.php
@@ -102,7 +102,10 @@ class Recovery extends Controller
             foreach ($data['list'] as $key => $value) {
                 $data['list'][$key]['is_cancel'] = 0;
                 $data['list'][$key]['is_success'] = 0;
-                $data['list'][$key]['recovery_image'] = !empty($image_list[$value['recovery_id']]) ?: '';
+                $data['list'][$key]['recovery_image'] = '';
+                if (!empty($image_list[$value['recovery_id']])) {
+                    $data['list'][$key]['recovery_image'] = $image_list[$value['recovery_id']];
+                }
                 if ($value['order_status'] == RecoveryStatusEnum::ACCEPTED) {
                     $data['list'][$key]['is_cancel'] = 1;
                     $data['list'][$key]['is_success'] = 1;